For pure value and fleet quality in Western and Central Europe, Sixt is the clear winner — you routinely get a BMW 3 Series or Mercedes C-Class for the price of a basic VW Golf elsewhere, and their mobile app makes the rental experience seamless. If your road trip crosses multiple borders, especially into Eastern Europe, the Balkans, or Turkey, Europcar has the most permissive policies and the widest network of 3,300+ locations, including small towns that Sixt and Hertz do not serve. Hertz is the premium choice for frequent renters and American travellers who value the Gold Plus loyalty programme (free upgrades, skip-the-counter pickup) and want a consistent, US-integrated booking experience. Our practical advice: search all three through an aggregator like DiscoverCars to compare real-time prices, then verify cross-border policies on the chosen company's website. Factor in young driver surcharges (EUR 10-25/day for ages 21-25), one-way drop-off fees (EUR 50-500), and automatic transmission availability before committing. Always pre-purchase third-party insurance to avoid costly counter upselling.
Hertz, Europcar, and Sixt collectively operate over 15,000 locations across Europe and account for roughly 55% of the continental car rental market. We compared them across 25 European cities with 60+ test searches, checking real-time pricing, fleet availability, cross-border policies, and post-rental customer experiences. Average weekly rental prices ranged from EUR 180 (Sixt in Germany) to EUR 320 (Hertz in Southern Europe), but the real differences emerge in fleet quality, cross-border restrictions, and the counter experience. With one-way fees varying from EUR 0 to EUR 500 depending on the company and route, choosing the right brand can save you hundreds of euros on a European road trip.
| Provider | Price | Fleet Quality | Customer Service | Cross-Border Policy | Loyalty Program |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hertz | ★★★☆☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★★★ |
| Europcar | ★★★★☆ | ★★★☆☆ | ★★★☆☆ | ★★★★★ | ★★★☆☆ |
| Sixt | ★★★★★ | ★★★★★ | ★★★★☆ | ★★★☆☆ | ★★★★☆ |
Scores are based on our hands-on testing, user reviews, and price monitoring across multiple European countries.
For pure value and fleet quality in Western and Central Europe, Sixt is the clear winner — you routinely get a BMW 3 Series or Mercedes C-Class for the price of a basic VW Golf elsewhere, and their mobile app makes the rental experience seamless. If your road trip crosses multiple borders, especially into Eastern Europe, the Balkans, or Turkey, Europcar has the most permissive policies and the widest network of 3,300+ locations, including small towns that Sixt and Hertz do not serve. Hertz is the premium choice for frequent renters and American travellers who value the Gold Plus loyalty programme (free upgrades, skip-the-counter pickup) and want a consistent, US-integrated booking experience. Our practical advice: search all three through an aggregator like DiscoverCars to compare real-time prices, then verify cross-border policies on the chosen company's website. Factor in young driver surcharges (EUR 10-25/day for ages 21-25), one-way drop-off fees (EUR 50-500), and automatic transmission availability before committing. Always pre-purchase third-party insurance to avoid costly counter upselling.
Data and regulations verified against official sources. Last checked 2026-04-27.
Sixt has the best fleet quality in Europe, offering premium German vehicles (BMW, Mercedes, Audi) as standard. Their cars average under 12 months old. Hertz vehicles are also well-maintained at under 18 months, while Europcar's fleet tends to be older at 24+ months.
Europcar has the most permissive cross-border policy, allowing travel to Eastern European countries including Croatia, Slovenia, and the Balkans. Hertz also has good cross-border flexibility. Sixt is the most restrictive, with many Eastern European countries requiring expensive add-ons or outright prohibited.
Sixt generally offers the most competitive pricing, especially in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland. Hertz is consistently 10-20% more expensive. Europcar falls in between but offers good value when booked through aggregators. Always compare through a site like DiscoverCars for real-time pricing.
Hertz Gold Plus Rewards is widely considered the best rental loyalty programme, offering free category upgrades, skip-the-counter pickup, and choice of vehicle from the Gold lot at major airports — all available from the first rental. Sixt+ subscription (EUR 299-599/month) is better for frequent renters who want unlimited vehicle swaps. Europcar's Privilege programme is less generous but offers free one-way domestic fees at Platinum tier and guaranteed upgrades.
Common hidden fees across all three companies include: airport surcharges (EUR 20-50), young driver fees for ages 21-25 (EUR 10-25/day), additional driver fees (EUR 8-15/day), one-way drop-off fees (EUR 50-500 depending on route), GPS rental (EUR 12-15/day — use your phone instead), fuel service charges if you do not return the tank full (EUR 2-3/litre markup), and late return fees (typically one extra day charged after 30-60 minutes). Cross-border fees add EUR 30-150 depending on destination countries.
It depends on the company. Europcar is the most permissive, allowing travel to Croatia, Slovenia, the Balkans, and even Turkey on some vehicle classes. Hertz allows most EU countries but restricts certain Eastern European destinations. Sixt is the most restrictive — Croatia, Serbia, Montenegro, Albania, and Turkey are either prohibited or require expensive add-ons of EUR 50-150. Always verify your specific route with the rental company before booking, as policies vary by pickup location and vehicle class.
Country-by-country driving requirements, packing list, and emergency contacts — all in one PDF.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.